Book a discovery call

Healthcare

Home care virtual assistant vs billing company: which seat first?

A home care virtual assistant covers office work like scheduling and intake. A billing company works your claims. Here’s how to tell which one you need first.

Hands typing on a laptop at a desk with stacked binders, folders and a calculator

Say it’s Monday morning at a small home care agency. A caregiver’s call-out is still sitting on the owner’s phone, and the rejected claims and aged AR haven’t moved. The budget this month covers one outsourced service, so the owner has to pick which problem to pay someone to fix first.

A home care virtual assistant handles the office side, mostly scheduling and intake. A billing company handles the claims cycle, from submission through to aged AR. Both can work inside the software your agency already runs.

Searches for “VA billing” also turn up Veterans Administration billing shops, which are a different service. Whether to keep billing in house at all is a separate decision, and Paradigm covers the home care version of it.

Most pages comparing the two are written for clinics. They set a clinic operations assistant against a clinic claims biller, or a clinic billing VA against a company paid a percentage of collections. Home care VA providers mostly list office tasks, and none of these pages help a home care owner who already has both backlogs work out which one is costing cash or coverage today.

What a virtual assistant does and what a billing company does

The unfilled shift is office work and the unposted remittance is billing work. They stay two different jobs even when a sales page puts both on one specialist.

Home care virtual assistant Billing company
The problem it solves Coverage and office work: shifts, intake, recruiting screens, EVV exceptions Cash: claims, posting, rejects, denials, aged AR
Typical work Scheduling, intake, recruiting screens, EVV exception cleanup, invoice and file follow-up Claim submission, payment posting, reject work, denials, aged AR follow-up
What “billing” often means on that sales page Invoices, reminders, files; on Atlas, visit confirmations, exception clean-up, and claim submission sit with one specialist The claims cycle
How you usually pay A monthly fee for one dedicated person A defined scope of claims work; clinic pages sometimes use a percentage of collections
Who you call about A stuck visit or an unfilled shift A stuck claim or an unposted remit
Where the work happens Agency software Agency system or database
What has to come first BAA before PHI BAA before PHI

The two are sold differently, but both can work on the same login. A billing company works the cash side: HHAeXchange’s RCM pages, for example, keep the claims cycle in the agency’s own system or database.

What “billing” means on a virtual assistant’s sales page

When a VA provider says “billing,” read the task list before you assume it covers claims. ClearDesk’s home care VA pages place the work in scheduling, intake and recruiting, and describe the billing side as invoice preparation and payment reminders, along with timesheet follow-up and file organization. That is office work.

Atlas Care’s back-office VA pages put scheduling, intake and EVV exception management on software the agency already uses. They also list an EVV & Billing Specialist who handles visit confirmations, exception clean-up and claim submission, so coverage work and cash work sit with one person. If you only need one of the two, check which tasks are actually on that list.

On clinic pages, a “billing VA” usually works claims on the practice’s own login, compared with a billing company that is paid a percentage of collections and reached through a portal. There, billing usually means claims.

So if a proposal titled “billing support” never mentions denials, and denials are your problem, that proposal doesn’t cover them.

Check this week’s backlog before you buy

Use the login you already have to find out which backlog actually held up cash or coverage this week:

  1. Open the scheduler or visit list. What didn’t get confirmed, whether call-outs, intake or EVV exceptions?
  2. Open claims, posting and the AR aging report. What didn’t get paid, such as rejects, denials or unposted remits?
  3. Which of the two blocked cash or coverage today?
  4. When the brochure said “billing,” did it name the claims work, or invoices and reminders?
  5. Write the work you want to hand off in one sentence before anyone gets a login.
  6. Make sure the BAA is dated before anyone sees PHI.

A visit that never got confirmed is a coverage problem. A confirmed visit that didn’t get paid is a cash problem. Whichever list didn’t move this week is the one to hand off first, and if both moved, pick the one that hits payroll this Friday. Either way, buy it as a defined job rather than a bag of hours.

Section 12006(a) of the 21st Century Cures Act mandates that states implement electronic visit verification for Medicaid personal care services (PCS) and home health services (HHCS) that require an in-home visit by a provider. EVV systems surface incomplete visits as exception lists, though the mandate doesn’t tell you which service to buy. To size what those exceptions cost your office each year, try the EVV exception cost calculator.

What stays with you after you hand off the work

Once routine work is written down with clear rules, someone else can do it. Some decisions still come back to you:

  • clinical exceptions
  • hiring decisions
  • payer relationships
  • the family calls you want to keep

The scheduler can’t attest to an EVV exception, because attestation belongs to the caregiver or the clinician, and a biller can’t write the clinical note a denial needs. A login gives someone access, not clinical or hiring authority.

You’ll know the handoff worked when the backlog moves on the login you already use. HHAeXchange describes working in the agency’s system, and that visibility is how you check. A number a vendor publishes about its own claims is not the test.

Sign a business associate agreement before anyone logs in

The HIPAA Rules permit a covered entity to disclose protected health information to a business associate if a written business associate agreement is in place. HHS names claims processing and billing as business associate activities.

45 CFR 160.103 treats workforce as persons whose conduct, in the performance of work, is under the direct control of the covered entity, paid or not. A business associate is a person who, other than as workforce, creates, receives, maintains, or transmits PHI on the covered entity’s behalf, including for claims processing and billing. An outsourced assistant or billing company that will see PHI is typically a business associate, which is why the agreement has to exist first.

HHS also states that a certificate is not that agreement. A covered entity is required to enter into a contract that meets 45 CFR 164.504(e). You still sign it, and your counsel should review it. This is not legal advice.

If you can’t yet say which backlog held up cash or coverage this week, start there. We take on one clearly defined piece of work, in your system, after the BAA is signed.

Back to all articles

Keep reading

An empty white chair at a dark wooden desk with a half-closed laptop and a mouse

Healthcare

Is outsourcing home health work HIPAA-safe?

Handing home health admin work to an outside team is not HIPAA-safe by default. It can be, once the BAA and unique logins are in place. Not legal advice.

Get new articles by email

Join Inside TrueNext for one short note a month on running outsourced operations well.

Please enter a valid email address.

One email a month. Leave any time in one click. Read our privacy policy.

You are in. Check your inbox for a welcome note from Inside TrueNext.
Chat on WhatsApp

Inside TrueNext

Get new articles by email

One short note a month on running outsourced operations well, with each new article as it lands.

Please enter a valid email address.

One email a month. Leave any time in one click. Read our privacy policy.

You are inCheck your inbox for a welcome note from Inside TrueNext.